Questions · At your child's school

Can a public school make my child read a book with sexual content for class?

Can a public school make my child read a book with sexual content for class?

You can ask, in writing, for the exact title and the passages at issue, and you can request an alternative assignment on religious grounds. Most districts have a written policy for parent objections to instructional material and an appeal path to the board. Put the request on paper, name the conviction plainly, and ask who decides and by when.

What is actually happening

A moral question has been handed to you dressed as a professional one. The assignment is defended as literary merit, grade-level appropriateness, or a selection made by trained staff, so that your objection looks like ignorance rather than conscience. What it is fishing for is your silence, or one angry outburst that lets the matter be closed as a behavior problem. If you go quiet, the book becomes settled precedent for every family behind you.

The expert wedge · Rule 3. Your objection is about purity and parental jurisdiction. It gets answered with curriculum theory, reading levels, and credentials, because that is ground you were never meant to be able to stand on. The point is not to persuade you but to disqualify you.

What Scripture says

“Finally, brethren, whatsoever things are true, whatsoever things are honest, whatsoever things are just, whatsoever things are pure, whatsoever things are lovely, whatsoever things are of good report; if there be any virtue, and if there be any praise, think on these things.” Philippians 4:8

What the book says · Chapter 18, The Mountain of Family: Protecting and Strengthening the Family Unit

“Activists introduce concepts of gender theory or sexual liberation into schools. They do not call it moral instruction, which would be the parent's domain. They call it comprehensive health education, which is the expert's domain. Then when a parent objects to explicit material, the institution answers that these materials were selected by credentialed experts and the parent is not an expert, so the objection is invalid.”

From Rules for Radical Christians, quoted exactly.

What the law generally says

In the United States, parents have generally been recognized as holding a protected interest in directing the upbringing and education of their children, though schools are also generally given wide latitude over curriculum. Many states have statutes or regulations allowing a parent to be notified of, and to excuse a child from, instruction dealing with sexuality or human reproduction, and some extend that to assigned reading. Most districts also maintain their own written policy for objecting to instructional material, often with a reconsideration committee and an appeal to the school board. Curriculum documents and book lists are frequently reachable through state open-records provisions. Which of these applies to you, and what the deadlines are, turns on your state and district, and that is what Ask looks up.

The words to use

"I am requesting an alternative assignment for my child for this title, because the sexual content in it conflicts with our family's religious convictions about purity. What is the district's written procedure for that request, who approves it, and when will I have an answer?"

Your move

  1. Email the teacher and ask for the title, author, the specific pages or scenes assigned, and a copy of the district policy on parental objections and alternative assignments. Ask for it in writing.
  2. Read the passages yourself before you say anything else. Quote the book, not your impression of it. Overstating what is in it is the one move that hands them the argument.
  3. Submit a short written request naming the assignment, stating the conviction without apology, and proposing a specific alternative book or paper so the answer cannot be that you offered nothing.
  4. Ask who decides and by what date, and ask for the board policy number and the appeal steps if the answer is no.
  5. Use Ask for your state to find the notification and opt-out provisions and the records process that apply where you live.
  • Document every date, name, and answer, and keep the email thread instead of taking calls.
  • Ask in writing that the alternative assignment be graded equivalently, so no penalty is buried in the accommodation.
  • Do not tell your child to refuse the work on his own. Get the exemption decided by adults, in writing, first.

Your situation, your state

This page is the general answer. Describe what is actually happening to you and Ask returns the answer for your situation and your state, with the law looked up and the exact words to use. Your first ask is free.

Ask about your situation

Not legal advice. When it stops being a conversation, a lawyer licensed in your state is the next call.

Watch it happen

The Field Cases are short narrated scenarios of believers in binds like this one, such as “The Disposition”, “The Hallway”, “The Room”, with the exact words that change the ground the fight is on.

Watch the Field Cases →

People in this situation also ask

Written from Rules for Radical Christians and Scripture by the same engine that answers Ask, and read by the author before it was published. Not legal advice.